The feed back from the crit was mostly positive, people seem to think i am moving in the right direction.
One of the main criticisms was that the stalled T-shirt was not consistent with the magazine logo. However I considered this and decided that I wanted the T-shirt to have a different feel to the magazine. It would have been very easy to slap a stalled logo on a T-shirt but I wanted the T-shirt to stand alone; while tying in with the stalled identity it should have its own style. I've produced an insert and tag to go in with the shirts to make it make it feel more consistent with the rest of the identity.